Developing Arts Literacies:
Analyzing and Evaluating - Critique
Communication and Collaboration
In this lesson, students will develop perspective about historical events through art, poetry, and music. Students will gain insight about how significant historical events can inspire art that conveys emotions and mood. This allows students to develop conceptual ‘big ideas’ about hardship, fairness, equity, and the quest to bring change for the better. After analyzing sculpture, poetry, and a musical composition, students will experiment with metaphors and create their own poetry.
Develop a familiarity with the origins of "The Black National Anthem" in reference to author, time, purpose, circumstance, and mood.
Analyze and discuss the figurative language and imagery of the poem to derive meaning from significant, historical events
Recognize the effect that music and rhythm have on written words. Teaching Approach
What You'll Need
1 Computer per Small Group
Teachers should be familiar with the civil rights movement in US history. Teachers can use this
Civil Rights Timeline to refresh their understanding.
Teachers will also need a basic understanding of the role James Weldon Johnson played as a civil rights activist during the Harlem Renaissance. Visit this website for a brief
Biography of James Weldon Johnson.
Teachers should be familiar with “Lift Every Voice and Sing (Black National Anthem),” performance is availble to watch in the Resource Carousel above. The text of the original poem, "Lift Every Voice and Sing," is also in the Carousel.
Prior Student Knowledge
Students should be comfortable working in pairs/quads. Also, they should have general knowledge about civil rights in the U.S. with post Civil War events to the early 1900’s. The students should know how to construct a biographical timeline to identify events in one’s life.
Students should have previously analyzed and interpreted visual art to explore and discover concepts.
Students should be familiar with metaphor used in poetry to help others gain perspective.
Large Group Instruction
Small Group Instruction
Preview sculpture and decide if a large image has clear resolution or to display in through a projector on the screen or wall, or on a white board, or a computer wired to a monitor or each pair of students has a copy of the visual representation of The Harp sculpted by Augusta Savage in 1939. A photograph of a scaled replica is located within the Resource Carousel available for you to use. Bookmark websites Copy for each student a black line master for analyzing sculpture(see TR#1 Picture Interpretation) Have a large area vertical, top-bottom board or chart paper to allow for students to assemble a timeline from a link provided with 81/2” x 11” print outs placed in a sequence of the civil rights related historical events.
Resources in Reach
Here are the resources you'll need for each activity, in order of instruction.
1. Display an image of the sculpture Don't tell students the name of the sculpture. Have students examine and discuss the sculpture. Explain that this sculpture was displayed at the 1939 New York World’s Fair and it stands about 16 feet high. using the Resource Carousel above. The Harp
2. Have students, in pairs or groups of four, examine this work of art and generate responses in lists to the following:
What are the things you could touch (people, places, or things) if you were looking at this work of art. e.g. man, God’s hand, people, muscles, family, instruments.
Things you could not touch (abstract nouns), e.g. strength, determination, pride, harmony, unity, hope, power
Action that is happening (verbs), e.g. holding, lifting, balancing, singing, harmonizing
Things you hear, see, smell, taste, feel (adjectives), e.g. soft voices, strong, closeness
3. Ask students why the artist chose to capture this particular image.
What title would you give this sculpture? Tell why.
After they have a chance to generate their own title and tell why, then share the name of the Sculpture:
The Harp sculpted in 1939 by Augusta Savage. She was inspired by the poem, written by James Weldon Johnson, Lift Every Voice and Sing, and the song written by his brother, Rosamond.
1. Have students explore the events leading up to and surrounding the time the poem was written in 1900. The purpose is to let the reader build their knowledge about civil rights and how this poem connects to history. This website by ThinkQuest provides students with a timeline of important events to the African American history.
2. Create a simple timeline on the board or a long sheet of butcher paper. Place the following dates leading to the writing of the poem on the timeline: 1600s, 1787, 1820, 1826, 1828, 1847, 1849, 1850, 1854, 1857, 1859, 1860, 1860-1861, 1861-1865, 1863, 1865, 1865-1877, 1868, 1870, 1896
3. Divide students into five groups. Each group will need to research 4 dates at ThinkQuest. Each group should read about the event(s) during the time periods they receive, then report to the class in one or two sentences summarizing the event(s) and placing it along the timeline in large classroom display. Have chalk/markers available to allow for students to piece the timeline together from earliest events to 1900(writing of the poem).
4. Add James Weldon Johnson to the timeline (1871-1938). Within the timeline in a contrasting color to allow students to underscore his experiences in context of significant historical events related to civil rights movement.
5. Have students read about You can also print and distribute the poem to students. Johnson. Display Johnson's poem, Lift Every Voice and Sing, on a whiteboard using the image gallery located within the Resource Carousel. Lift Every Voice and Sing
6. Ask students to think carefully and describe what types of feelings the poem evokes. Explain that poems, like music, use words to affect the emotions of the audience. The teacher can model a ‘think aloud’ with a line or stanza and then draw an inference about feelings, mood.
1. Explain that the poem Explain to students that words of a song are called Lift Every Voice and Sing was set to music by the poet's brother, J. Rosamond Johnson. lyrics. Now they are going to examine how the poem's words take on a different level of meaning when set to music.
2. Ask students what kinds of music they listen to. What is special about music that creates special feelings, memories, or meanings?
3. Have students listen to the anthem’s message of unifying African Americans in their struggle for equal rights in this country.
4. Have students watch the musical version of "Lift Every Voice and Sing" in the resource carousel above.
5. Have students discuss the effect of the music on the words of the poem.
How does the music affect the mood and emotion of the lyrics?
What do you think the singer(s) wants listeners to feel when they hear the song?
What emotions or feelings to you hear? Joyfulness, sadness, anything else?
How does one person singing (solo) compare to a group of people singing together?
Why do you think people sing together, such as in a choir?
6. Discuss the rhythm in the music selection. Ask students to identify the tempo of each the piece. Do they prefer a fast tempo or a slow one? Why?
7. Compare and contrast the words as a poem with the words set to music. Which has more of an effect on them? Which do they prefer? Why?
8. Analyze poem for use of descriptive language. Tell students to highlight keywords that create an image in their mind or establish feeling or mood. For example:
We have come over a way that with tears have been watered
Till earth and heaven ring, Ring with the harmonies of Liberty
9. Think aloud the imagery from those key words. Model think aloud: I see African Americans marching with hope that they will be treated with fairness and equality.
The Harp from the Engage step and select a noun from the lists students created.
The vocabulary the students brainstormed will provide rich content for them to create an individual stanza of a poem about
The Harp. Have each group member individually write a line of poetry about
The Harp. Then have groups put their lines together into a stanza. (Remind students that poems don't always have to rhyme)
Have students draw a picture of their group's stanza on a seperate sheet.
Students should then bring their images to a section of the wall and create a large picture moasic.
Explain that moasics could be described as image poems.
Extending the Learning
Have students read their class poem. Ask them to think about what they see as they read each line. What images come to mind?
Does the moasic that they created reflect the images they think about when they read their poem?
Common Core State Standards Initiative seeks to bring diverse state curricula into alignment through a set of common learning goals and assessments. In 2010, Standards were released for English language arts and mathematics. Common standards have not yet been released for science, social studies, and other subject areas, including the arts. In addition, some states have yet to, or have chosen not to, adopt the Common Core standards.
During this transitional period, A rtsE dge will present all relevant state and nationals standards as they apply to our lessons.
National Standards for Arts Education
For the full text of the content and achievement standards in Arts Education, visit our
Lessons connect to the National Standards for Arts Education, the Common Core Standards, and a range of other subject area standards.
Common Core/State Standards
Select state and grade(s) below, then click "Find" to display Common Core and state standards.